|
|
Volume
6: No. 2, April 2009
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Body Weight Dissatisfaction Among Israeli Jewish and Arab Women With Normal or Overweight-Obese Body Mass Index,
Israeli INHIS-1, 2003-2004
Amanda Niskar, DrPH, Orna Baron-Epel, PhD, Noga Garty-Sandalon, RD, MSc, Lital
Keinan-Boker, MD, PhD
Suggested citation for this article: Niskar A, Baron-Epel O, Garty-Sandalon N, Keinan-Boker L. Body weight dissatisfaction among Israeli Jewish and Arab women with normal or overweight-obese body mass index. Prev Chronic Dis 2009;6(2):A51. http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2009/
apr/08_0118.htm.
PEER REVIEWED
Abstract
Introduction
In Israel, 58.9% of Jewish and Arab Israeli women aged 25 to 64 years are overweight or obese (body mass index ≥25
kg/m2). The objective of this analysis is to describe body weight dissatisfaction differences between Jewish and Arab Israeli women with normal or overweight-obese
body mass index.
Methods
This analysis included 1,393 Jewish and Arab women who participated in the Israeli National Health Interview Survey, 2003-2004. The survey covered a random sample of the Israeli general population aged 21 years or older. All variables were based on self-report. Body weight dissatisfaction was a multiple-choice question in the survey that offered the following responses: very satisfied, satisfied, reasonably satisfied, not satisfied, or very unsatisfied. Univariate and multivariate analyses were
conducted.
Results
Overall, 39.1% of Jewish women reported body weight dissatisfaction, compared with 29.1% of Arab women. Older overweight-obese Arab women had a lower prevalence of body weight dissatisfaction than Jewish women of the same age group,
which indicates cultural differences in body weight dissatisfaction among older overweight-obese women. However, cultural differences do not
appear to influence body weight dissatisfaction among younger Jewish and Arab women of normal weight.
Conclusion
This study suggests that Jewish and Arab women differ in their perceptions of body weight. Interventions tailored to each group are needed to promote healthy dietary and physical activity behaviors.
Back to top
Introduction
More than 400 million adults are estimated to be obese worldwide (1). In Israel, the prevalence of overweight and obesity among Jewish and Arab women aged 25
to 64 years is 58.9% (2). Study samples vary by many factors such as nationality, race, and ethnicity. Thus, results from studies among different populations cannot
necessarily be generalized to other populations. A study in Israel among Arab women showed similar findings to studies on US populations regarding an association
of increased body mass index (BMI) with onset of type 2 diabetes (3). Despite the public health risks associated with overweight and obesity, we know of no data
that describe the relationship between body weight dissatisfaction (BWD), overweight-obese BMI, dieting, and population group among Israeli women. Understanding the possible relationship between BWD, BMI, dieting, and population group among Israeli women is of interest to Israeli health professionals delivering health care services
including preventive services to the diverse populations of Israeli women who are in varying levels of acculturation. In addition, findings
of this study are relevant to providing health care services to similar populations living in other countries.
Israel is a complex country that is pluralistic, multicultural, and
democratic (4). Israel’s national health care system is highly developed, and
national health insurance covers the entire population. Israel is a small
country with approximately 29,000 km2 of land (4). The approximately 7.3 million
people of Israel
originate from more than 30 countries (4). The 2 major ethnic populations are Jews (approximately 80%) and Arabs (approximately 20%), and Israel has 2
official languages, Hebrew and Arabic (4). These 2 populations differ by language, religion, and culture.
Studies describe minority and immigrant populations living in Israel, Australia, and other countries whose weight-related values and behaviors are similar to those of
Westernized white women as they become acculturated (5,6). People’s food consumption is sensitive to changes in food portion size, the number of people with whom they eat, the amount of food that others eat, and the variety of foods available (7,8). These external environmental factors may explain
the finding that body weight
often increases or decreases when people move from one area of the world to another, when they enter the college environment, or when they have a change in marital or relationship status (7). Stress-induced eating may be another factor that contributes to the development of obesity (9). Chronic life stress seems to be associated with a greater preference for energy- and nutrient-dense foods high in sugar and fat (9).
Factors associated with BWD include body weight, muscle tone, and body fat (10). Cultural attitudes regarding appearance, physical activity, and health influence BWD (11). In Israel, married women and women with low education are at risk for a sedentary lifestyle, which relates to cultural attitudes about physical activity and may be associated with modernization (12). Identifying factors associated with BWD among Israelis could help health professionals develop tailored interventions to
promote healthy weight for Israelis (13). The objective of this analysis is to describe the nationally representative prevalence of BWD among Jewish and Arab Israeli women with normal or overweight-obese BMI, by age, dieting status, education, smoking status, and general health status.
Back to top
Methods
Survey framework
The Ministry of Health’s Israel Center for Disease Control (ICDC) conducted the first Israeli National Health Interview Survey (INHIS-1)
during 2003 and 2004 (14). Informed consent for each participant was obtained by telephone
after a brief explanation about the health survey, including the objectives and importance. People who consented by telephone to participate in the survey were interviewed and were told they could stop the interview at any point and could decline to answer any
question at any time. According to Israeli legislation, such a telephone health survey is conducted within the capacity of the ICDC and is not considered medical research. Thus, no approval of an ethical committee was needed for this data collection and analysis.
The INHIS-1 data are nationally representative of the Israeli general population, including the Arab population. INHIS-1 was based on the European Health Interview Survey (EUROHIS) framework initiated in 2000 by the World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe.
In 2000 and 2001, EUROHIS field tests were conducted in participating countries, including Israel (15).
INHIS-1 sample
The study sample consisted of a random sample of the Israeli citizen general population aged 21 years and older. Telephone numbers were selected from a computerized list of national telephone company subscribers estimated to cover 94% of Israeli households, according to
the Central Bureau
of Statistics (16). The 6% of the population without a national telephone company subscription are likely to have a subscription with another telephone service provider. These other telephone service
providers were not accessible in the computerized list used for random selection of survey participants.
INHIS-1 data collection
The ICDC prepared the EUROHIS questions for application in Israel. The 150 EUROHIS questions were translated into Hebrew and back into English to ensure correct translation. INHIS-1 included 142 EUROHIS questions after 8 questions not relevant to the Israeli population were removed. An additional 129 questions relevant to the Israeli population (eg, regarding population group) or related to specific topics of interest were added to INHIS-1 for a total of 271 questions. The Hebrew
questionnaire was then translated into Arabic and Russian and translated back into Hebrew for quality control. The questionnaire was administered over the telephone by trained interviewers from the corresponding population group in Hebrew, Arabic, or Russian. Data
were entered and analyzed with a statistical package developed for INHIS-1, and logic checks were performed.
INHIS-1 women’s health module
The findings presented in this analysis are results from the INHIS-1 women’s health module (WHM), conducted in 2003. The WHM included the 86 core questions from INHIS-1 and an additional 66 questions relevant to the women of Israel (part of the additional questions described in the above section) to monitor health status and to evaluate the use of health services and health behaviors specific to women. Although modules were not validated, they were pilot tested. For the WHM, 1,491
(27.5%) households could not be located, and 3,927 households from the INHIS-1 were contacted. Households were identified as lost to follow-up after 6 failed attempts to contact the household. The response rate for the WHM was 60.9%. Nonresponses included outright refusals, partially completed interviews, and repeated postponements. Three women did not provide population group data. A total of 1,393 women provided population group data and were available for analysis (1,065 Jewish and 328
Arab). This random sample is nationally representative of the Israeli Jewish and Arab populations.
Definitions
All variables were based on self-report. Key variables for this analysis were defined
on the basis of the survey questions. Population groups were organized into 2 categories: Jewish women or Arab women (Muslim, Christian, and Druze). The survey included other categories of women who did not identify themselves as Jewish Israeli or as Arab Israeli but because their numbers were so small they were designated Jewish Israeli, in accordance with INHIS-1 methods and because these women have similar sociodemographic characteristics to Jewish Israelis.
BWD is a valid assessment commonly used in studies and surveys (17,18). BWD was a multiple-choice question in the survey with 5 possible answers. For this analysis, the 5 categories were grouped into 2 categories: satisfied (0 = very satisfied, satisfied, and reasonably satisfied) or dissatisfied (1 = not satisfied, very unsatisfied). In the survey, women who reported being on a diet were asked to specify 4 diet categories: dieting for weight reduction, dieting for weight maintenance, dieting
for health reasons, or dieting for weight gain. For analyses, dieting was grouped into 2 categories: dieting (1
= for weight reduction or weight maintenance) or not dieting (0). Dieting for weight reduction or weight maintenance was the dieting category of interest for this analysis because we were interested in the increasing trends of obesity and overweight among Israeli women. Dieting for weight maintenance is included in the dieting category because the purpose of dieting is to avoid gaining
weight and to maintain health.
BMI was calculated as the reported weight without clothes and shoes divided by the square of the reported height without shoes. This analysis is interested in obesity issues and focused on the differences between women of normal BMI and women of overweight or obese BMI. These
2 BMI categories are defined by the World Health Organization as 18.5 kg/m2 to 24.9
kg/m2 (normal BMI) or 25.0 kg/m2 or more (overweight-obese BMI) (1). General health status was reported
as 1 of 5 categories (good, very good, fair, bad, very bad). For this analysis, general health status was defined in 2 categories as optimal (1 = good, very good) or suboptimal (0 = fair, bad, very bad).
Statistical analyses
Univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted by using SAS version 9.1 (SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, North Carolina). The
effect of population group (Jewish or Arab Israeli women) and BMI on BWD was assessed by age group. Except for the logistic regression modeling, all P values were the results of a χ2 test. The percentage of women dieting was assessed by BWD, BMI, and population group. To estimate the independent associations of each variable on BWD, χ2 statistics and multiple logistic regression models were conducted with BWD as the dependent variable. Odds ratios
and 95% confidence intervals were calculated for each variable, controlling for other variables in the final logistic regression model.
Significance was set at a P value of <.05. Confounders adjusted for in the final logistic regression model are population group, age, BMI, dieting, marital status, health status, and education.
Back to top
Results
Overall demographic characteristics of the Israeli population in 2003 are
described in Table 1. Characteristics of the INHIS-1 sample by Jewish and Arab women are presented in
Table 2. In this survey, 39.1% of Jewish women and 29.1% of Arab women reported BWD. Among overweight-obese women, 67.6% of Jewish women and 44.9% of Arab women reported BWD. Among overweight-obese women, 45.9% of Jewish women and 39.3% of Arab women with BWD reported dieting for weight reduction or weight maintenance. The percentage of normal-BMI women dieting for weight reduction or weight maintenance was
not significantly different between Jewish (20.9%) and Arab (21.4%) women.
Results of the multivariate analyses are presented in
Table 3. Smoking, physical activity, and having children were not included in the logistic regression model displayed in Table 3 because these variables were not significantly associated with BWD in either population. Interaction terms between population group, age, BMI, and dieting were not significant in logistic regression modeling.
Back to top
Discussion
This is the first analysis describing BWD among Jewish and Arab Israeli women. Differences in the prevalence of BWD were found between these 2 populations. In this INHIS-1 analysis, Arab women were less likely than Jewish women to report BWD. A higher percentage of Arab women than Jewish women were overweight-obese. Another recent Israeli survey that measured body weight found Arab women have a higher rate of obesity than Jewish women (2). Our finding that BWD was associated with an
overweight-obese BMI and dieting to lose or maintain weight is consistent with other international research showing that dieting is a common weight-loss strategy among women with BWD (19,20). Chronic dieters are likely to have BWD (11), and older overweight or obese women may have a history of unsuccessful weight loss attempts resulting in depression and BWD (21). A study in South Africa examined the prevalence of BWD in both normal and overweight glucose-intolerant nondiabetic women
(18). Both overweight and normal-weight glucose-intolerant women experienced a chronic dieting mindset, binge or uncontrolled eating, and feelings of guilt or depression after a binge in conjunction with BWD (18).
The Israel Heart Fund develops health promotion projects in the community to focus on special populations such as Arab women to prevent and reduce obesity (22).
A main finding of this study is the difference in BWD among young Arab women
compared with older Arab women. Muslim Arab people in Israel have a history of
less educational attainment than Jewish people in Israel (23). Cohorts born from
the mid-1920s to the 1970s experienced a narrowing of population group
differences in educational attainment at the lower levels of schooling, but the
differences increased at higher levels of education (23).
Our findings that BWD is associated with sociodemographic factors such as population group are consistent with previous studies in America and Europe (20,21). Overweight and obese US minorities were more likely to believe and to self-report that they were not overweight than were nonminorities (24). Targeted media campaigns and culturally tailored community educational events are examples of strategies to raise awareness about healthy living to promote healthy eating and healthy physical
activity patterns among US minority populations (25).
Our finding showing that older overweight-obese Arab women reported a lower prevalence of BWD than Jewish women of the same age group may reflect a difference in the degree of urbanization and industrialization between Jewish and Arab Israelis (26). The morbidity and premature mortality
seen in the Arab population is higher than that of the Jewish population (27). This finding that Arab overweight-obese women were more likely to be satisfied with their weight is of concern, because their obesity
rates place them at higher risk for developing chronic disease. For example, the prevalence of diabetes is higher among Arab Israelis than among Jewish Israelis (27). Approximately two-thirds of Israeli Arabs diagnosed with type 2 diabetes were women, and most of these women had a higher BMI at diagnosis of type 2 diabetes than did men (3).
Although older Arab and Jewish women differed in terms of BWD, our results demonstrated a similar prevalence of BWD among young Jewish and Arab women. The similarities among Arab and Jewish young women’s attitudes to body weight may suggest that the Arab community is in transition from a more traditional and collective way of life to a more individualistic way of life, adopting more modern lifestyles (26). Similarly, immigrants who lived in Israel for 4 to 15 years adopted Israeli
cultural norms for eating patterns related to obesity and eating disorders (6).
A major strength of this analysis is that the results are nationally representative for adult women in Israel. INHIS-1 is
among the largest national surveys in Israel, and this is the first time that BWD was studied in Israel. The
BMI calculations in our study are limited by the self-reporting method
of gathering height and weight data. Most women underestimate their weight and overestimate their height, resulting in BMI miscalculations (28). The degree of self-report weight inaccuracies can vary by population group (29), and chronic dieters are likely to overestimate their body weight (11). Actual height and weight measurements would be more reliable for studies calculating BMI. Another strength of this analysis is that multivariate analyses were conducted with and without controlling for
education, income, and employment, and the same differences were observed, which indicates that cultural issues may explain the differences rather than income or education.
Conclusion
Israeli Jewish and Arab women differ with regard to BWD. To prevent eating disorders and chronic diseases, Israeli women need to balance healthy behaviors and body weight attitudes. Interventions should be tailored to age group, education level, religion, marital status, language, and cultural traditions to promote satisfaction with normal BMI and to prevent obesity and related chronic diseases. Interventions are needed to promote proper nutrition, regular physical activity, and stress-reduction techniques (9,13). Some evidence suggests that eating is an automatic behavior that is not strongly influenced by nutrition education and that physical activity cannot compete with increased consumption of food (8). Therefore, additional interventions are needed that shape the external environment relevant to person, place, and time of food purchase, preparation, and consumption (7). Public health professionals in other countries with minority and immigrant populations may consider
developing interventions to prevent obesity that are tailored to age group, religion, language, and culture of each population group.
Back to top
Acknowledgments
We thank Professor Manfred S. Green, Ms Rita Dichtiar, Ms Tamar Peled-Leviatan,
Ms Anneke Ifrah, and the INHIS-1 interviewers, Israel Center
for Disease Control, Ramat Gan, Israel, for their contributions to
this manuscript.
The manuscript does not
necessarily reflect the views of the Israel Ministry of Health.
Back to top
Author Information
Corresponding Author: Amanda Niskar, DrPh, Office of Preparedness and Emergency
Operations, Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response, US Department of
Health and Human Services, 330 Independence Ave SW, Rm G644, Ste
320, Washington, DC 20201. E-mail:
amanda.niskar@hhs.gov. At the time this
article was prepared, Dr Niskar was affiliated with Tel Aviv University, Tel
Aviv, Israel.
Author Affiliations: Orna Baron-Epel, University of Haifa, Israel; Noga Garty-Sandalon,
Israel Center for Disease Control, Ramat Gan, Israel; Lital Keinan-Boker,
University of Haifa, Israel and Israel Center for Disease Control, Ramat Gan,
Israel.
Back to top
References
- Obesity and overweight: fact sheet no. 311. Brussels (BE): World Health Organization; 2006.
- Keinan-Boker L, Noyman N, Chinich A, Green MS, Nitzan-Kaluski D.
Overweight and obesity prevalence in Israel:
findings of the first National Health and Nutrition Survey (MABAT). Isr Med Assoc J 2005;7(4):219-23.
- Abdul-Ghani, MA, Kher J, Abbas N, Najami T.
Association of high body mass index with low age of disease onset among Arab women with type 2 diabetes in a primary care clinic. Isr Med Assoc J 2005;7(6):360-3.
- Israel Ministry of Tourism. Israel wonders. http://www.goisrael.com/Tourism_Eng/. Accessed July 30, 2008.
- Ball K, Kenardy J.
Body weight, body image, and eating behaviours: relationships with ethnicity and acculturation in a community sample of young Australian women. Eating Behav 2002;3:205-16.
- Greenberg L, Cwikel J, Mirsky J.
Cultural correlates of eating attitudes:
a comparison between native-born and immigrant university students in Israel. Int J Eating Dis 2007;40(1):51-8.
- Levitsky DA.
The non-regulation of food intake in humans: hope for reversing the epidemic of obesity. Physiol Behav 2005;86:623-32.
- Cohen DA, Farley TA. Eating as an automatic behavior. Prev Chronic Dis 2008;5(1).
http://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2008/jan/07_0046.htm.
- Torres SJ, Nowson CA.
Relationship between stress, eating behavior, and obesity. Nutr 2007;23:887-94.
- Delores J.
Gender differences in body mass index and weight loss strategies among African Americans. J Am Dietetic Assoc 2003;103(10):1360-62.
- Gingras J, Fitzpatrick J, McCargar L.
Body image of chronic dieters: Lowered appearance evaluation and body satisfaction. J Am Dietetic Assoc 2004;104 (10):1589-92.
- Baron-Epel O, Haviv A, Garty N, Tamir D, Green MS.
Who are the sedentary people in Israel? A public health indicator. Isr Med Assoc J 2005;7(11):694-99.
- Riebe D, Blissmer B, Greene G, Caldwell M, Ruggiero L, Stillwell KM, et al.
Long-term maintenance of exercise and healthy eating behaviors in overweight adults. Prev Med 2005;40(6):769-78.
- Israel Center for Disease Control. Israeli National Health Interview Survey (INHIS-1) 2003-2004. Jerusalem (IL): Ministry of Health; 2006.
- World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe. EUROHIS. Developing common
instruments for health surveys. Amsterdam (NL): IOS Press; 2003.
- Central Bureau of Statistics. Statistical abstract of Israel 2003. Jerusalem (IL): State of Israel, (document no. 54); 2003.
- Sikand G, Carter JE, Balucanag R, Hsu J. Women, weight dissatisfaction and subclinical eating disorder attitudes and behaviors. J Am Diet Assoc 1998;98(9):A79.
- Mczia Z, Goedecke JH, Steyn NP, Charlton K, Puoane T, Meltzer S, et al.
Development and validation of instruments measuring body image and body weight dissatisfaction in South African mothers and their daughters. Public Health Nutr 2005;8(5):509-19.
- Malinauskas BM, Raedeke TD, Aeby VG, Smith JL, Dallas MB.
Dieting practices, weight perceptions, and body composition:
a comparison of normal weight, overweight, and obese college females. Nutr J 2006;5:11.
- McElhone S, Kearney JM, Giachetti I, Hans-Joachim FZ, Martinez JA.
Body image perception in relation to recent weight changes and strategies for weight loss in a nationally representative sample in the European Union. Public Health Nutr 1999;2(1a):143-51.
- Anderson LA, Eyler AA, Galuska DA, Brown DR, Brownson RC.
Relationship of satisfaction with body size and trying to lose weight in a national survey of overweight and obese women aged 40 and older, United States. Prev Med 2002;35(4):390-6.
- Israel Heart Fund. Transforming medical research into medical practice. http://www.israelheartfund.org/index.htm. Accessed July 26, 2008.
- Okun BS, Friedlander D.
Educational stratification among Arabs and Jews in Israel: historical disadvantage, discrimination, and opportunity. Popul Stud 2005;59(2):163-80.
- Bennett GG, Wolin KY.
Satisfied or unaware? Racial differences in perceived weight status. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Activity 2006;3:40.
- Yancey AK, Kumanyika SK, Ponce NA, McCarthy WJ, Fielding JE, Leslie JP, et al. Population-based interventions engaging communities of color in healthy eating and active living:
a review. Prev Chronic Dis 2004;1(1).
www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2004/jan/03_0012.htm.
- El-Ghannam AR. Modernisation in Arab societies: The theoretical and analytical view. Int J Sociol Soc Policy 2001;21(11/12):99-100.
- Israel Center for Disease Control. The health status of the Arab population in Israel 2004. Jerusalem (IL): Ministry of Health; 2004.
- Engstrom JL, Paterson SA, Doherty A, Trabulsi M, Speer KL.
Accuracy of self-reported height and weight in women:
an integrative review of the literature. J Midwifery Womens Health 2003;48(5):338-45.
- Gillum RF, Sempos CT.
Ethnic variation in validity of classification of overweight and obesity using self-reported weight and height in American women and men: the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Nutr J 2005;4:27.
Back to top
|
|
